When are we really going to change our policies, mindset, expectations, and provide the appropriate support to develop the renewable energy industry? We can be operating with more renewable energy every year but it takes persistence and a unilateral commitment to the long term goal. The renewable energy industry is going to require long term bi-partisan support programs. The trillions of dollars of investment in fossil fuels did not happen overnight and the renewable energy industry simply has little or no chance of competing against it. We need to accept this fact and move on to support the industry or simply let the renewable energy industry develop ad hoc and see what happens. We have to face the facts that our energy demands are only going to increase and fossil supplies are a limited commodity.
The government must provide the support necessary to develop and sustain a strong US renewable energy industry. The infrastructure investments require solid long term support. Adequate capital will not flow into new industries where you are the underdog and existing energy players can squash your efforts with minuscule amounts of money compared to their profits. Investments must be enhanced through fair guaranteed minimum returns.
The expiration of the bio-diesel tax credit at the end of 2009 started a chain reaction which has basically shut this industry down. The bio-diesel industry had already been hurt significantly by the drop in fuel prices during the economic down turn and the loss of the tax credit has added further strain.
The entire renewable energy industry would benefit immensely by using a price based model which allows investors to know that they will be guaranteed a fair return on their investments. We can forget the tax credits, blenders credits, producers credits, production tax credits, investment tax credits, and roll them into one universal renewable energy program.
If we define base technologies which are covered and appropriate margins for each we would have a self regulating system which would spur new investment in proven technologies and eliminate the subsidies when market prices provided the necessary support for the projects.
Maybe it is as simple as new wind power projects get $0.XX per kwh which is the baseline industry standard given reasonable production and fair investor return.
Biomass and CHP systems could have their own rates which ensured a fair return based on a processing spread between the biomass cost and the energy revenues.
You could use a crush margin for ethanol. The commodity prices for corn, ethanol, and energy will fluctuate but if you can control the crush margin you can secure investor concerns. This would also work for cellulosic ethanol, biodiesel, and other advanced biofuels as their technology was approved for the program.
The program would be available for facilities using approved technologies and production methods. This would help new technology companies focus on getting their processes approved and ready for commercial application. This would hopefully move the technology risk to the venture capital markets and away from the government as is currently common. The majority of the tax payers money should go towards development of proven technologies and renewable energy supply, not betting on the next technology breakthrough. The government's exposure to this risk should be limited, a small portion of the overall programs, and limited to specific areas which need to be boosted to meet renewable energy goals.
This universal renewable energy program can provide the structure for moving the capital into these companies as new technologies are proven, added to the approved list, and taken to market.
We need to help our government officials on both sides understand that renewable energy is not a "nice to have" option. It is something we "need to have"
Showing posts with label biomass supply. Show all posts
Showing posts with label biomass supply. Show all posts
Wednesday, May 5, 2010
Monday, January 25, 2010
Biomass Supply Challenges for the Renewable Industry
I wanted to share a little of the information from a white paper we wrote last year which combined and analyzed information from a few of the government studies which have been published regarding biomass supply. The paper identifies some of the biomass sources and talks about how as we develop commercial scale biomass based projects the sustainable production and logistics of providing biomass is going to be the major contributor to the success of the project outside the processing technology itself. If you are interested in receiving the “Feedstock Supply Solutions for Biomass Based Renewable Energy Companies and Rural Economic Development” white paper drop me a note and I will send a copy.
In this white paper we discuss how the actual demand for biomass is may go well beyond the billion tons per year as mentioned in these studies as economic conversion technologies develop. We contend that it will be 1.2 - 2.0 billion tons per year in the foreseeable future depending on our desire to reduce dependence on fossil fuels. It also details existing biomass resources and opportunities.
Let's take a quick look at the biomass sources.
Forest Biomass - The DOE/USDA Billion - Ton report shows 368 million tons of forest resources available annually in the US. This breaks down into 141 million tons in use already, 139 million tons available with better land management, and 88 million tons not currently utilized. This leaves 227 million tons potential forest based biomass for use.
Municipal Solid Waste (MSW) - MSW Municipal solid waste is getting much attention as a potential feedstock for renewable applications. MSW has some very attractive qualities. It is a feedstock which is generated in center of population. The use of MSW has tremendous greenhouse gas benefits with reductions in methane production and landfill storage requirements. MSW has it's own challenges as a feedstock. We have not studied MSW in detail as it is not currently a part of our operating plans. If future conversion methods for MSW can economically generate liquid fuels or syngas it will be very beneficial.
Agricultural Resources - The DOE and USDA joint report, “Biomass as a Feedstock for a Bioenergy and Bioproducts Industry: The Technical Feasibility of a Billion-Ton Annual Supply,” lays out in great detail three possible scenarios for the availability of biomass feedstock from agricultural lands. In the first scenario with moderate yield increase and no perennial energy crops indicates about 421 million tons annual capacity. In the highest capacity scenario with high yield increases and perennial energy crops the annual capacity is 997 million tons per year. This indicates that agricultural resources can be utilized to produce a significant and possibly the largest portion of our biomass energy feedstock.
The economical challenge with all biomass sources is the delivered price to the conversion facilities. The aggregation and transportation can quickly drive the prices for biomass feedstock out of the economical price range for the conversion facility. The existing market demand is also a concern in biomass sourcing. If a facility will increase regional demand for biomass significantly there will likely be an increase biomass prices overall. Knowing the other uses for biomass and their acceptable levels of feedstock cost is also very important. The facility operator who requires the lowest cost feedstock in the region will surely experience economic troubles down the road.
In order for the biomass industry to grow and survive long term the biomass feedstock supply chain stakeholders need to focus on increasing the production per acre and reducing the total costs to the conversion facility. Conversion facility owners and operators also need to participate in the feedstock supply chain by supporting the producers and developing technologies which will help them reduce the overall costs of biomass to the facilities.
The consistent economical feedstock supply for biomass based operations will continue to be the major challenge in scaling and industry growth. Companies that do not understand the biomass capacity and sourcing very well will not survive.
In this white paper we discuss how the actual demand for biomass is may go well beyond the billion tons per year as mentioned in these studies as economic conversion technologies develop. We contend that it will be 1.2 - 2.0 billion tons per year in the foreseeable future depending on our desire to reduce dependence on fossil fuels. It also details existing biomass resources and opportunities.
Let's take a quick look at the biomass sources.
Forest Biomass - The DOE/USDA Billion - Ton report shows 368 million tons of forest resources available annually in the US. This breaks down into 141 million tons in use already, 139 million tons available with better land management, and 88 million tons not currently utilized. This leaves 227 million tons potential forest based biomass for use.
Municipal Solid Waste (MSW) - MSW Municipal solid waste is getting much attention as a potential feedstock for renewable applications. MSW has some very attractive qualities. It is a feedstock which is generated in center of population. The use of MSW has tremendous greenhouse gas benefits with reductions in methane production and landfill storage requirements. MSW has it's own challenges as a feedstock. We have not studied MSW in detail as it is not currently a part of our operating plans. If future conversion methods for MSW can economically generate liquid fuels or syngas it will be very beneficial.
Agricultural Resources - The DOE and USDA joint report, “Biomass as a Feedstock for a Bioenergy and Bioproducts Industry: The Technical Feasibility of a Billion-Ton Annual Supply,” lays out in great detail three possible scenarios for the availability of biomass feedstock from agricultural lands. In the first scenario with moderate yield increase and no perennial energy crops indicates about 421 million tons annual capacity. In the highest capacity scenario with high yield increases and perennial energy crops the annual capacity is 997 million tons per year. This indicates that agricultural resources can be utilized to produce a significant and possibly the largest portion of our biomass energy feedstock.
The economical challenge with all biomass sources is the delivered price to the conversion facilities. The aggregation and transportation can quickly drive the prices for biomass feedstock out of the economical price range for the conversion facility. The existing market demand is also a concern in biomass sourcing. If a facility will increase regional demand for biomass significantly there will likely be an increase biomass prices overall. Knowing the other uses for biomass and their acceptable levels of feedstock cost is also very important. The facility operator who requires the lowest cost feedstock in the region will surely experience economic troubles down the road.
In order for the biomass industry to grow and survive long term the biomass feedstock supply chain stakeholders need to focus on increasing the production per acre and reducing the total costs to the conversion facility. Conversion facility owners and operators also need to participate in the feedstock supply chain by supporting the producers and developing technologies which will help them reduce the overall costs of biomass to the facilities.
The consistent economical feedstock supply for biomass based operations will continue to be the major challenge in scaling and industry growth. Companies that do not understand the biomass capacity and sourcing very well will not survive.
Labels:
biomass sourcing,
biomass supply,
forest biomass
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)